India: Announced lawsuit challenging MeitY's rules pertaining to identification of fake content against the government on social media (Kunal Kamra v Union of India and Others)

Description

Announced lawsuit challenging MeitY's rules pertaining to identification of fake content against the government on social media (Kunal Kamra v Union of India and Others)

On 10 April 2023, a Petition was filed in the High Court of Bombay challenging the Information Technology Amendment Rules, 2023 (IT Rules 2023), directing social media intermediaries to remove any news related to the Central Government deemed fake, false or misleading by a government-established Fact-Check Unit (FCU). The plaintiff alleged that the IT Rules 2023 conflict with Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000, which provides a safe harbour for intermediaries, protecting them from liability for user-generated content unless notified by the Central Government through a court order. The plaintiff argued that the IT Rules 2023 bypass this court order requirement, allowing the government to act as both Judge and Prosecutor, violating the Indian Constitution by restricting freedom of speech and hindering political satire. The plaintiff, therefore, sought a stay on forming the FCU under the IT Rules 2023.

Original source

Scope

Policy Area
Content moderation
Policy Instrument
Content moderation regulation
Regulated Economic Activity
platform intermediary: user-generated content
Implementation Level
national
Government Branch
judiciary
Government Body
court

Complete timeline of this policy change

Hide details
2023-04-10
under deliberation

On 10 April 2023, a Petition was filed in the High Court of Bombay challenging the Information Tech…

2024-03-11
concluded

On 11 March 2024, the High Court of Bombay refused to grant an interim stay on establishing a Fact-…

2024-03-15
under appeal

On 15 March 2024, the Plaintiff moved to the Supreme Court of India seeking an interim stay on the …

2024-03-21
under investigation

On 21 March 2024, the Supreme Court of India stayed the notification of a Fact-Check Unit (FCU) und…

2024-09-20
in force

On 20 September 2024, the Bombay High Court issued a ruling in a lawsuit concerning the government'…